ISSN 0130-0083
En Ru
ISSN 0130-0083
The poem “Song about the refractor”: scientific humor in the context of relations between Russian and German scientists at the turn of the 19th and 20th centuries

Abstract

The history of science is intended to study not only the history of discoveries, hypotheses and methodology, but also human connections, which sometimes infl uence the formation and development of scientific knowledge no less than articles and books. Ephemerides of various kinds are particularly diffi cult to observe and study: topical hints understood only in a narrow circle, various statements on a subject that may be forgotten aft er the passage of time, a way of joking that has long since lost its relevance — all that is woven into the fabric of life, including scientific one, and without which it is impossible to imagine people who did science. At the center of the article is a poetic text found in the archive of the remarkable Russian astronomer V.K. Tserasky, who headed the Astronomical Observatory of Moscow University at the turn of the 19th and 20th centuries and put a lot of eff ort into its construction. The humorous work “Song about the Refractor” (1898) by the Berlin student Benno Messow is one of such samples of humor, which can shed light on the nature of scientifi c contacts between scholars from diff erent countries. The poem is a paraphrase of Friedrich Schiller’s famous “Song of the Bell”, deeply rooted in the tradition of German poetry. Meanwhile, the parodic “song” was presented to V.K. Tserasky, who, according to the presenter’s thought, was able to appreciate the subtlety of the joke. The construction of a refractor in the Moscow observatory seemed an excellent occasion to reuse the text dedicated to the completion of the same device in the Potsdam Astrophysical Observatory. This work is a testimony both to the scientists’ penchant for humor and to the versatile scientifi c and friendly ties between scholars and engineers of Russia and Germany at the turn of the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. The article examines Messow’s poem, some details of his biography and the alleged circumstances of the song’s transfer to V.K. Tserasky.

References

Blazhko S.N. Istoriya astronomicheskoy observatorii Moskovskogo universiteta v svyazi s prepodavaniyem astronomii (1824–1920) [History of the Astronomical Observatory of Moscow University in the Context of Teaching Astronomy (1824–1920)] // Uchenyye zapiski MGU. Jubilee series. 1940. Issue 58. P. 5–106.

Broglie L., de. Po tropam nauki [On the Paths of Science]. Moscow: Izdatel’stvo inostrannoy literatury, 1962. 408 p.

Götz M. Dr. Benno Messow “Das Lied vom Refraktor” // Sternzeit–Zeitschrift astronomischer Vereinigungen. 1987. N 3. S. 76–79.

Gribko L.P., Ponomareva G.A. Russkiye astronomicheskiye sektsii XIX — nachala XX veka: Vitol’d Karlovich Tseraskiy i Lidiya Petrovna Tseraskaya [Russian Astronomers of the Late 19th and Early 20th Centuries: Vitold Karlovich Tserasky and Lydia

Petrovna Tserasky] // Istoriko-astronomicheskiye issledovaniya [Historical and Astronomical Studies]. Issue XLI. Voronezh: IIYET RAN, 2021. P. 187–247.

Mentsin Yu.L., Samus’ N.N. Poema Benno Messowa “Pesn’ o refraktore”, podarennaya V.K. Tseraskomu [Benno Messow’s Poem “Song about the Refractor”, Presented to V.K. Tserasky] // Istoriko-astronomicheskiye issledovaniya [Historical and Astronomical Studies]. Issue XXXIX. 2016. P. 433–463.

Mitteilungen der Naturforschenden Gesellschaft Bern aus dem Jahre 1942. Bern: Naturforschenden Gesellschaft , 1943. LX, 227 S.

Schorr R. Benno Messow // Astronomische Nachrichten. 1930. Bd. 239. Hft . 4. Nr. 5716. S. 63–64.

PDF, ru

Received: 04/06/2023

Accepted date: 04/30/2024

Keywords: Moscow University; Astronomical Observatory; V.K. Tserasky; history of science; scientific relations; humor in scientifi c environment

Available in the on-line version with: 30.04.2024

To cite this article:
Issue 5, 2023