Abstract

By the mid-sixteenth century, the Vorotynsky princes were highly sought aft er for their military service within the Russian state. Th e brothers of the Vorotynsky family served as regimental commanders, at times leading substantial independent fi eld formations, in addition to garrisons of major cities and fortresses. In the autumn of 1562, however, the Vorotynsky family fell into disgrace. Th is decline was particularly marked in the case of Prince M.I. Vorotynsky and his brother A.I. Vorotynsky, whose lands were confi scated (Prince V.I. Vorotynsky had already died). Th e severity of the disgrace is also refl ected in its duration; for the elder brother, it ended only in 1565. Mikhail Ivanovich and his wife were imprisoned in Beloozero, while Aleksandr Ivanovich and his wife were detained in Galich. As a result, the Vorotynskys, who were major generals, were permanently expelled from the Russian voivodeship corps. Th e reasons for the disgrace of the Vorotynskys have been a subject of speculation among experts. One commonly held view is that it was a consequence of Ivan IV’s desire to destroy the vast Vorotynsky Principality, refl ecting the course of the Tsar’s land policy. Conversely, alternative theories have postulated that the Vorotynskys’ decline can be attributed to the prevailing political dynamics of the era. Th e present author puts forward an alternative hypothesis, namely that the Vorotynskys were punished for their failure to defeat the Crimean Khan Devlet-Giray near Mtsensk in the summer of 1562. Th e Khan managed to evade capture and retreat onto the steppes, thereby circumventing a potential defeat at the hands of the Russian voivodes. Th is outcome is attributed to the Prince M.I. Vorotynsky’s slowness in command, specifi cally with regard to the Russian troops’ defensive formation. Th is event is likely to have resulted in the monarch’s censure of the prince’s performance in a senior position. During deliberations among experts specializing in the military and political history of the Russian Empire, analogous assumptions have been posited on at least two occasions. A.A. Zimin and V.P. Ul’yanov have expressed views that are similar to these. Th e present author’s position differs from that of his predecessors in terms of its validity, which is derived from a meticulous examination of the sources, specifi cally razriad (register) records and chronicles.

References

Kafedra novoy i noveyshey istorii: lyudi i traditsii [Department of New and Modern History: People and Traditions] / Ed. by L.S. Belousov. Saint Petersburg: Aleteia, 2020. 466 p. (Trudy istoricheskogo fakul’teta MGU [Proceedings of the Faculty of History of Moscow State University]. Issue 184. Series II. Istoricheskiye issledovaniya [Historical Researches], 119).

Karpov S.P. Razmyshleniya o ponimanii istorii i problemakh istoricheskogo obrazovaniya [Refl ections on the Understanding of History and the Problems of Historical Education]. Moscow: RAN, 2019. 48 p.

Kollektsiya Vladislava Mal’kevicha — dar Moskovskomu universitetu: nauchnyy katalog [Vladislav Mal’kevich’s Collection, a Gift to Moscow University: Scientific Catalogue] / M.V. Abayeva, E.D. Agapova, A.Yu. Vyrva et al.; intr. by series editorin-chief V.A. Sadovnichiy; intr. by A.L. Rastorguyev, M.Yu. Savel’yeva; biography by D.A. Andreev; ed. by M.Yu. Savel’yeva; coordinator L.A. Polunina; ill. by F.V. Cherkashin. Moscow: Izdatel’stvo Moskovskogo universiteta, 2024. 396, [4] p. (Zolotoy fond MGU [Th e Golden Fund of MSU]).

Skvoz’ gody i pokoleniya. K 85-letiyu kafedry etnologii istoricheskogo fakul’teta Moskovskogo universiteta [Through Years and Generations. To the 85th Anniversary of the Department of Ethnology of the Faculty of History at Moscow University] / Ed. by T.D. Solovey, O.E. Kaz’mina, M.N. Bakhmatova. Saint Petersburg: Aleteia, 2024. 356 p. (Trudy istoricheskogo fakul’teta MGU [Proceedings of the Faculty of History of Moscow State University]. Issue 270. Series II. Istoricheskiye issledovaniya [Historical Researches], 186).

Traditsii i novatsii prepodavaniya istochnikovedeniya, istoriografi i i metodov istoricheskikh issledovaniy. K 70-letiyu kafedry istochnikovedeniya istoricheskogo fakul’teta MGU imeni M.V. Lomonosova i 100-letiyu so dnya rozhdeniya akademika I.D. Koval’chenko (1923−2023) [Traditions and Innovations of Teaching Source Studies, Historiography and Methods of Historical Research. To the 70th Anniversary of the Department of Source Studies of the Faculty of History at Lomonosov Moscow State University and the 100th Anniversary of the Birth of the Full Member of the RAS I.D. Koval’chenko (1923–2023)] / Ed. by A.G. Golikov. Saint Petersburg: Aleteia, 2023. 252 p. (Trudy istoricheskogo fakul’teta MGU [Proceedings of the Faculty of History of Moscow State University]. Issue 243. Series II. Istoricheskiye issledovaniya [Historical Researches], 167).

Traditsii izucheniya kul’tury v Moskovskom universitete: laboratoriya istorii kul’tury [Traditions of Cultural Studies at Moscow University: Th e Lab of Cultural History] / Ed. by L.V. Koshman. Saint Petersburg: Aleteia, 2019. 92 p. (Trudy istoricheskogo fakul’teta MGU [Proceedings of the Faculty of History of Moscow State University]. Issue 145. Series II. Istoricheskiye issledovaniya [Historical Researches], 87).

Trudy kafedry drevnikh yazykov [Proceedings of the Department of Ancient Languages]. Issue V. Kafedre drevnikh yazykov istoricheskogo fakul’teta MGU — 80 let [Th e Department of Ancient Languages of the Faculty of History at Moscow State University Is Commemorating Its 80th Anniversary] / Ed. by A.V. Podosinov. Moscow: Indrik, 2018. 272 p. (Trudy istoricheskogo fakul’teta MGU [Proceedings of the Faculty of History of Moscow State University]. Issue 118. Series IV. Biobibliografi i [Biobibliographies], 5).